The Great Harness Hunt
Let me tell you about the time I took my dog, Bailey, to the pet store to buy his first “proper” harness. Picture a grown adult standing in the middle of the harness aisle for 45 minutes, paralyzed by indecision, while a Labrador mix patiently sits nearby, occasionally sighing in a way that can only be described as judgmental.
“This one? No, maybe this one… Wait, what about this one?”
Bailey eventually laid down and took a nap. The store employee avoided eye contact after the third time I asked about the difference between a Y-shaped harness and a H-shaped harness. In my defense, there were at least 30 different options, all promising to be THE solution to all my dog-walking problems.
Sound familiar? Don’t worry—you’re not alone in the harness confusion. And unlike me on that fateful day, you now have this handy guide to help you navigate the wide world of dog harnesses without having your dog question your decision-making abilities.
Why Harness Type Actually Matters
Before we dive into the harness fashion show, let’s get something straight: picking the right harness isn’t just about what looks cute (though we do love those stylish prints at Ruffinitely). The right harness can:
- Prevent injuries to your dog’s trachea and neck
- Provide better control without causing discomfort
- Address specific issues like pulling or training needs
- Accommodate your dog’s unique body shape and size
- Make walks more comfortable for both you and your pup
Remember the time Bailey slipped out of his too-loose collar during a squirrel sighting? Three blocks, one muddy creek, and several apologies to startled picnickers later, I learned that proper fit isn’t optional—it’s essential.
The Harness Lineup: Finding Your Perfect Match
1. Back-Clip Harnesses: The Everyday Classic
Best for: Well-trained dogs who don’t pull much, small breeds, dogs with neck issues
Back-clip harnesses feature a leash attachment point on the back, between the shoulder blades. They’re the most common type you’ll see, and for good reason—they’re easy to put on and comfortable for most dogs.
Pros:
- Easy to put on and take off
- Comfortable for most dogs
- Doesn’t restrict natural movement
- Great for casual walks and everyday use
Cons:
- Doesn’t discourage pulling (can actually make it easier for your dog to pull)
- Less control for reactive dogs
Real-life scenario: Bailey wears his Ruffinitely Comfort Mesh Harness for our regular neighborhood strolls. It’s perfect because he’s past his pulling phase (mostly), and the breathable mesh keeps him comfortable during summer walks.
2. Front-Clip Harnesses: The Pulling Problem-Solver
Best for: Dogs who pull on leash, training sessions, reactive dogs
These harnesses have the leash attachment at the center of the chest. When your dog pulls, the design causes them to be turned toward you instead of continuing forward.
Pros:
- Discourages pulling without pain or discomfort
- Gives you more control and steering ability
- Great training tool for teaching loose-leash walking
Cons:
- Can restrict shoulder movement if worn for too long
- May require more adjustments to fit properly
- Some dogs get tangled in the leash
Real-life scenario: Remember my neighbor’s German Shepherd, Rex? He was such a puller that his owner, Mark, developed what he called “leash walker’s elbow.” After switching to the Ruffinitely No-Pull Training Harness, Mark no longer needs to brace himself like he’s water skiing behind his dog.
3. Dual-Clip Harnesses: The Versatile Virtuoso
Best for: Dogs in training, versatile use, owners who want options
As the name suggests, these harnesses offer both front and back attachment points, giving you the flexibility to choose based on the situation.
Pros:
- Adaptable to different situations and training stages
- Allows you to transition from training to regular walking
- Often made with more padding and adjustability
Cons:
- Usually more expensive
- Can be bulkier than simpler designs
- More straps and buckles to adjust
Real-life scenario: My friend Jamie uses a dual-clip harness for her Border Collie, Einstein. During their agility training, she uses the back clip for freedom of movement, but switches to the front clip when they’re navigating crowded farmer’s markets. The Ruffinitely Dual-Control Harness has been their go-to for two years.
4. Step-In Harnesses: The Easy-Entry Option
Best for: Dogs who hate things going over their head, small breeds, seniors with mobility issues
Step-in harnesses lay flat on the ground, allowing your dog to literally step into them before you secure them on top.
Pros:
- Great for head-shy dogs
- Simple design with minimal straps
- Easy to put on squirmy dogs
- Good for arthritic owners (less bending and adjusting)
Cons:
- Can be less secure if not properly adjusted
- Limited control for strong pullers
- Fewer adjustment points for custom fitting
Real-life scenario: My sister’s dachshund, Frank, transforms into a wiggle monster whenever anything goes near his head. After several comical harness-application attempts (one ending with my sister accidentally wearing the harness), the Ruffinitely Step-In Mesh Harness became their saving grace. Frank now happily steps into his harness with no drama.
5. Padded/Vest Harnesses: The Comfort Kings
Best for: Dogs with sensitive skin, long walks/hikes, broad-chested breeds
These harnesses distribute pressure across a wider area with soft padding, making them extra comfortable for active dogs or those with skin sensitivity.
Pros:
- Superior comfort for extended wear
- Distribute pressure evenly across the chest
- Often include additional features like handles or reflective trim
- More secure fit for escape artists
Cons:
- Can be hot in warm weather
- Take longer to dry if they get wet
- Sometimes harder to adjust precisely
Real-life scenario: Bailey and I once went hiking with my friend and her Pitbull, Rosie. While Bailey was comfortable in his regular harness, Rosie needed something with more support for her broad chest. The Ruffinitely Adventure Vest Harness was perfect for her muscular build and provided extra control on the mountain trails.
6. Y-Shaped Harnesses: The Athletic Supporter
Best for: Active dogs, sports and agility, dogs who need full shoulder movement
These harnesses form a Y-shape across the dog’s chest, following the natural shape of their muscles without restricting shoulder movement.
Pros:
- Allows full range of motion for active dogs
- Follows natural contours of canine anatomy
- Minimal rubbing on armpits
- Great for running, hiking, and dog sports
Cons:
- Less control than some other styles
- Can be trickier to fit properly
- Not ideal for strong pullers
Real-life scenario: My cousin’s Border Collie, Zip, competes in agility trials. After noticing Zip was hesitating slightly before jumps, they switched to a Y-shaped harness that freed up his shoulder movement. The difference was immediate—Zip moved more naturally and confidently with his Ruffinitely Active Dog Y-Harness.
The Great Measurement Adventure
If there’s one piece of advice I can’t emphasize enough, it’s this: MEASURE YOUR DOG PROPERLY!
Remember my first attempt at buying Bailey a harness online? I eyeballed his size and confidently ordered a “medium” because, well, he looks medium-sized to me. When it arrived, it fit him like a dog bikini rather than a proper harness. Lesson learned.
Here’s how to get it right:
- Chest girth: Measure the widest part of your dog’s chest, usually just behind the front legs.
- Neck girth: Measure around the base of your dog’s neck where a collar would sit.
- Weight: Some harness sizes are also determined by weight range.
- Breed guidelines: Check if the manufacturer provides breed-specific recommendations.
Pro tip: If your dog falls between sizes, go with the larger size and make sure it’s adjustable.
Common Harness Mistakes (That I’ve Definitely Made)
The Houdini Effect
Some dogs could give escape artists a run for their money. Bailey once slipped out of a poorly fitted harness during a thunderstorm and led me on a rain-soaked chase through the neighborhood. I learned that you should be able to fit two fingers (but not more) between the harness and your dog’s body.
The Armpit Chafe
Notice your dog walking strangely or showing less enthusiasm for walks? Check for chafing, especially in the armpits. Bailey developed a little bald spot before I realized his harness was rubbing him the wrong way.
The Wrong-Purpose Purchase
Using a standard walking harness for joring or other pulling sports? Recipe for disaster (and possibly injury). Make sure your harness is designed for its intended use. My friend learned this the hard way when her “car safety harness” broke on a sudden stop—it was never designed for that purpose despite the misleading product description.
The “They’ll Grow Into It” Myth
Puppies grow quickly, but an oversized harness is a safety hazard in the meantime. Bailey’s first harness had so much extra room that he could have sublet the space to a smaller dog.
Making the Transition: When Your Dog Thinks the New Harness Is a Monster
So you’ve chosen the perfect harness, but your dog freezes like a statue when you try to put it on? Don’t worry, you haven’t wasted your money. Many dogs need time to adjust to new gear.
Try this approach:
- The introduction: Let your dog sniff and examine the harness before trying to put it on.
- The treat association: Place treats on or around the harness to create positive associations.
- The gradual approach: First just touch the harness to your dog, then drape it over them without buckling, then attempt one arm at a time.
- The distraction technique: Use treats, toys, or another person to distract while you quickly get the harness on.
Bailey initially treated his new harness like it was covered in dog-eating monsters. A week of patience (and many treats) later, he was shoving his head through the opening before I even asked.
The Right Harness Makes All the Difference
Finding the perfect harness may take some trial and error, but the payoff is worth it. A well-fitted, appropriate harness can transform walks from stressful to joyful, give you better communication with your dog, and prevent injuries down the road.
At Ruffinitely, we believe that every dog deserves gear that’s as unique as they are. Whether your pup is a dedicated puller, a sensitive soul, or an athletic adventurer, there’s a perfect harness match waiting for them.
And remember—if you’re standing in the pet store aisle having an existential crisis about harness types, you’re not alone. We’ve all been there, and our dogs have the photos to prove it.
What harness type works best for your dog? Share your experiences in the comments below! And check out our complete collection of harnesses to find your perfect match.
Related Articles:
